So Skype 3.0 is out of beta, I am yet to be impressed.
While the interface now looks a bit better and functionally easier for users to get Skype functional I was disappointed to start seeing bloat. The RAM that Skype now uses is up around 30 MB. The Skype client itself is taking 12 MB on it’s ow, the other 20 MB is an application called skypePM.exe. It is the Extras Manager. Damn if that ain’t bloat I don’t know what is. This is optional on the install. It may well explain why my computer now takes an aeon to load as well. I will be uninstalling and reinstalling with this feature out.
Then there is the recording issue. As regular readers would know I have been harping on about the ability to record Skype for ages. But since Skype is yet to build this ability in I have and used Hot Recorder, it worked beaut. Until Skype 3.0 showed up, it now successfully records silence. Sure the new Skype as the old Skype could be used with a plug-in, now “Extras” that are able to record. One hot tip; none of these applications are able to record Skype with anywhere near the quality required for podcasting. So what now Skype? It looks to me that Skype are going to rely on 3rd party applications to take up the slack in the recording department. A shame because Skype would produce the best one. These other applications are lacking the quality required.
The positives while there, are hard to find for me. The audio quality seems to have improved, so that is a good thing. The other thing that has improved that may or may not have to do with Skype is that file transfers seem faster. Nothing huge but they are no longer dismal. The integration of Skypecasts is a good one.
Speaking of Skypecasts, having them in the interface of Skype is great. I have never heard one before today. The fact that they are in the interface meant that they were easy to access and that the ones there were on then or starting soon. So I thought that I would pay one a visit. It was great fun and I was able to network with a few people and added them to my Skype contacts. I even meet up with another Australian podcaster! Small world.
The cast was a computer help one that offered people that had joined the opportunity to have their questions answered or a problem sorted. Which is a great idea and people seemed to take advantage of getting some real-time assistance with what they were trying to do. Far less formal than a podcast it offers a great forum.
I was surprised at the sound quality which was good. Although the quality of other participants was the limitation. Some “callers” I am sure were on dial-up, given how it sounded! But most people had reasonable connections. It was fun and I’ll be doing it again. The other thing is that you could easily listen to a Skypecast and do something else at the same time. Does that make me a lurker?
This is the extent of my experience with the new Skype. I hope that it improves and I feel a bit better about it in time.
So my mixed feelings on Skype continue. I sincerely hope that they keep their focus on call quality and just consider including a RECORD button for future releases (I would even pay for it). Some nice improvements. Regular users will find it a worthy upgrade, not much here for the person that has special requirements and the bloat is not necessary in my opinion. I certainly feel that this is the most corporate version to evolve so far. A sign of the times? Only that very thing will tell. But with over 7 million Skypers on-line as I write this who am I to argue?
NOTE: The Hot Recorder Homepage is broken and this product is no longer developed from my experience.
December 15, 2006 at 10:05 am
I am happy that you mentioned Skype Extras.
Check out http://www.BitWine.com we have an extra there that let you charge for your calls.
Tools -> Do more -> Featured -> BitWine
If you register add the Widget to your blog so people can call you and pay for your expertise if you ask for them to.
December 15, 2006 at 3:36 pm
[…] I just installed Skype 3.0, because I’m slow so we’ll report back on that feature set as well. Although I’ve heard good things from Sebastian Prooth on his blog. So check back for Our take on it. The Flip side of this coin is obviously Dave Gray yes the Rooster him self has some very seemingly valid critiques of the application. Creeping feature ism is definitely a problem with modern software. All Bloat no bang. Had to come back and edit this article after reading Dave’s post. Tech Tags: skype promotion promo free call alndline US sebrt caffination prooth […]